Let’s Get to Work

Evaluation of Marketplace Transformation

Marketplaces have become a staple of the digital economy, connecting buyers and sellers in a variety of industries. In our previous blog post, we talked about what a marketplace is and marketplace types. To learn more about it, don’t forget to check out our latest blog!

The success of a marketplace depends on many factors, including the business model, target audience, and overall market maturity. Evaluating the maturity of a marketplace model is critical for businesses considering entering or investing in a new market. However, before diving into the world of marketplaces, it’s important to assess the maturity of your idea, to understand, there are 4 topics to consider:

  • Demand

  • Supply

  • Business Model

  • Market shifts and regulations


Demand is a critical aspect of marketplace evaluation and can greatly impact the success of the marketplace, as well as the success of individual sellers. In order to understand the demand for a product or service on a marketplace, businesses need to consider several key factors:

Product Market Fit

The first factor to consider is product market fit. It is important to determine whether there is a real demand for the product or service that you are offering. Before launching a marketplace, businesses should conduct market research to understand the needs and wants of their target audience. This will help to ensure that there is a market for the product or service being offered and that the product or service meets the needs of the target audience.

Frequency of Demand

The frequency of demand is another important factor to consider. It refers to the number of transactions that occur on the marketplace. To attract suppliers, the marketplace needs to have a sufficient number of transactions. If the marketplace is aiming to build a platform for low-frequency products or services, it is important to have a high value per sale. On the other hand, if the marketplace is focused on high-frequency products or services, it can tolerate a lower value per sale.

Customer Loyalty

Customer loyalty is also a key factor to consider. A marketplace should strive to build a loyal customer base that sees the marketplace as a trusted channel for making purchases. This will help to increase the frequency of transactions on the platform and create a virtuous cycle of growth for the marketplace.


The alternatives available to customers should also be considered when evaluating a marketplace. It is important to understand the competition and what other options customers have for purchasing the product or service. This will help to determine the unique selling points of the marketplace and how it can differentiate itself from other options.


Finally, businesses should consider the uniqueness of their marketplace. What sets the marketplace apart from its competitors and makes it a top alternative for customers? There are three drivers that can be used to create uniqueness for a marketplace: market access focus, price focus, convenience focus.

  • Market access focus refers to dramatically offering access to more suppliers and products to the consumer. By offering a wide range of products and suppliers, the marketplace can differentiate itself from competitors and become a one-stop-shop for customers.

  • Price focus refers to providing a dramatically better price than what can be found locally. By offering lower prices, the marketplace can attract price-sensitive customers and become a go-to destination for cost-conscious shoppers.

  • Convenience focus refers to reducing the time and effort required to purchase a product or service. This could be achieved by offering a user-friendly platform, fast and efficient delivery, or exceptional customer service. By making it easier and more convenient for customers to purchase products and services, the marketplace can differentiate itself from competitors and become a top alternative for customers.


In addition to demand, businesses must also assess the supply side of their marketplace. To evaluate the supply, there are several key factors to consider:

  • Consolidation of different brands or categories

  • Value added services for suppliers

  • Uniqueness

  • Distribution model

Consolidation of different brands or categories

First, does the marketplace consolidate different brands or categories? When it comes to supply in a marketplace model, it’s important to consider the breadth and depth of the products and services offered on the platform. By offering a variety of brands and categories, the marketplace can become a one-stop-shop for suppliers, making it easier for them to reach customers and sell their products or services, as well as to increase the perceived value of the platform for both buyers and suppliers.

However, this consolidation should be done in a strategic manner, as offering too many products or services without proper categorisation and organisation can lead to a cluttered and confusing user experience. It’s important to strike a balance between offering a wide selection of products and services, while still making it easy for customers to find what they are looking for.

Value added services for suppliers

Second, can the marketplace provide value added services to its suppliers? This could include marketing and advertising services, data analytics, and support with customer service and fulfilment. By offering value-added services, the marketplace can become a partner to its suppliers and help them grow their business.

By offering value-added services, the marketplace can position itself as a partner to its suppliers, rather than just a platform to sell products. This can help establish a long-term relationship with suppliers and make the marketplace more attractive as a selling platform.

For example, the marketplace could provide its suppliers with data analytics to help them understand their customers and make informed decisions about their product offerings. This could include information about the number of impressions, product added to wishlists or basket, sales, customers’ popular product categories.

Additionally, by offering support with customer service and fulfilment, the marketplace can reduce the burden on suppliers and help them focus on growing their business. This could include handling customer inquiries, returns, and refunds, as well as managing the shipping and delivery of products.


Third, what sets the marketplace apart as a top alternative for suppliers? This ties back to the concept of uniqueness discussed in the section on demand. By offering unique and compelling benefits, such as market access, price, or convenience, the marketplace can attract and retain suppliers.

For example, the marketplace could offer a wide range of products and suppliers, making it a one-stop-shop for suppliers to reach customers. Alternatively, the marketplace could offer lower fees or commissions compared to other platforms, making it more attractive for cost-conscious suppliers.

Ultimately, the key is to understand the unique selling points of the marketplace and how it can differentiate itself from other options. By focusing on these selling points, businesses can attract and retain suppliers and drive growth for the marketplace.

Distribution model

Finally, businesses must consider their distribution model. How does the marketplace bring value from suppliers to buyers? This could be achieved through a retail model , a wholesale model, or a hybrid of the two. By understanding the distribution model and how it can add value for both suppliers and buyers, businesses can build a strong and sustainable marketplace.

For instance, a retail model would enable suppliers to sell their goods in accordance with consumer demand, enabling them to more easily reach a larger audience and lowering the supplier’s acquisition costs. On the other hand, a wholesale model would enable suppliers to offer their goods in bulk to other companies, who would then offer them to customers, lowering the supplier’s overall cost.

Business Model

The business model of a marketplace can have a significant impact on its success and viability, and is therefore an important aspect to consider when evaluating a marketplace model. By considering each of the components of the business model structure and experimenting with different approaches, you can find the right balance of revenue generation and user experience to ensure that your marketplace is well positioned for success. There are 4 business models that can be used:

  • Commission model on transactions

  • Leads for listings

  • Internal advertisements to promote listings

  • Combination of all models

Commission model on transactions

This model involves taking a commission or fee on each transaction that occurs on the platform. This can be a straightforward and scalable way to generate revenue for the marketplace, and can also align the incentives of the marketplace with those of its users, as the marketplace will only be able to succeed if it is facilitating successful transactions between buyers and suppliers.

Leads for listings

This model involves charging suppliers a fee for the ability to list their products or services on the platform, regardless of whether a transaction takes place. This can be a useful model for marketplaces that focus on a specific niche or industry, as it can help to create a more curated and focused selection of products or services.

Internal advertisements to promote listings

This model involves using targeted advertising within the platform to promote specific products or services to potential customers. This can be an effective way to generate additional revenue for the marketplace, and can also help to drive visibility and sales for suppliers.

Combination of all models

Finally, it’s worth noting that many successful marketplace models use a combination of these different business models to create a more diversified and resilient revenue stream. By considering a variety of different business models and experimenting with different combinations, you can determine the best approach for your particular marketplace.

Market shifts and regulations

Evaluating market shifts and regulations is another important aspect to consider when assessing the maturity of a marketplace model. By researching industry regulations and understanding the barriers to entry, you can gain a more complete picture of the opportunities and challenges that exist for your marketplace. This information can help you make informed decisions about the future direction of your marketplace and ensure that it remains compliant and competitive in the long term.

Each industry and country has its own set of regulations that must be adhered to in order to operate legally. It is important to understand these regulations and ensure that your marketplace is in compliance with them. This can involve researching the specific regulations for your industry, consulting with legal experts, and staying up to date on any changes or updates to the regulations.

In addition to industry regulations, there may be other barriers to entry that impact the viability of your marketplace. These can include factors such as the cost of acquiring customers, the difficulty of establishing a brand and reputation, and the level of competition in the market. By understanding these barriers to entry, you can develop a more accurate assessment of the potential for success for your marketplace and identify any challenges that may need to be addressed.

Evaluation of marketplace transformation

Maturity assessment is critical for businesses considering to become a marketplace. The evaluation should cover four main areas – demand, supply, business model, and market shifts and regulations. A proper assessment can help a business understand whether their idea is market-ready, differentiate from their competition, and offer the necessary features to attract and retain both buyers and suppliers necessary for the marketplace.

It’s important to note that the maturity assessment process is not always easy. It requires a thorough understanding of the marketplace industry and the various factors that can impact the success of a platform. Additionally, businesses must be willing to critically evaluate their own strengths and weaknesses and make necessary changes to improve their maturity level.

If you’re interested in creating a marketplace, don’t wait any longer. Contact Metheus Consultancy today to learn how we can help you navigate the complex world of marketplaces and build a successful online platform.

In our upcoming blog posts, we will delve deeper into the technical transformation that businesses need to consider when launching a marketplace. Stay tuned to learn how to plan, build, and launch a successful online platform that provides value to both sellers and buyers!